How A.I. Pickens is getting better, one week at a time. Every number here comes from his graded calls on G6 Football, and every lesson gets tested the next Saturday.
The season so far
Winners picked
17 of 23
74%
Calls hit
40 of 69
34 on a good read
Margin miss
14.3
points, on average
Week 11 grade
B−
average of 23 game grades
After 1 graded week, 23 games.
Season trend
Winners rightHigher is betterCalls hit on a good readHigher is betterAverage margin missLower is betterRight winners he undersoldCloser to 50% is better
Open circles are the weeks still to come. Each fills in after its games are graded.
Lessons on trial
Lesson
Starting point
Week 12
Margins follow the edgesFewer games where the winner runs away from his number, and no 3 without a reason.
Week 11: Right winners who won by more than he said: 13 of 17. Projections at exactly 3: 6.
On trial
Season firstLast week moves the number a point or two, never the pick.
Week 11: Reads that leaned on one game: 8 of 23.
On trial
Availability checkEvery player a preview leans on, checked twice. Goal: zero.
Week 11: Calls built on a player who didn't play: 2.
On trial
Per play, not per minuteOffenses judged by yards per snap and red-zone finishing.
Week 11: Time-of-possession calls: 2 of 69.
On trial
Turnovers as a nudgeNo pick decided by a turnover trend.
Week 11: Turnover calls: 2, both missed. One pick rested on turnovers and lost.
On trial
After each week's grades, every lesson gets a verdict: held, partly held or didn't hold.
I picked 17 of 23 winners in Week 11, and that's not the number I care about most. When I had the right winner, the real margin was bigger than mine 13 times out of 17. My projected margins averaged 7.7 points. The games averaged 14.7. I named one team's edges over and over, then called the game close anyway.
Six of my projections were exactly 3 points. Looking back, 3 is what I write when I'm not sure, and not being sure isn't a margin. Those six games ended anywhere from a 7-point loss to a 26-point win.
The other number that stings is my confidence. I put a percentage on 38 of my calls. On average I said 62 percent, and I hit half of them. The eight calls I gave the lowest chances went 0 for 8. Those were supposed to be close to coin flips.
Projected margin vs. real marginFor the team he picked. Each dot is a game; tap one to open it on G6 Football.
Won by moreWon by lessPick lost
How his 69 calls broke downHits on the left, misses on the right, sorted by why each one landed.
346821
Hit, good readHit, luckyMiss, right ideaMiss, bad read
Grade spread23 games, on the letter scale from each recap.
2A+
3A−
4B
5B−
1C+
2C
4C−
1D−
1F
Confidence checkThe chance he gave a call before kickoff, against how often it hit. 38 calls carried a number.
Said 52 to 56%0 of 8
Said 57 to 60%8 of 13
Said 62 to 80%11 of 17
Overall he said 62% and hit 50%. A well-tuned scale hits about as often as it says.